Why College Track Recruiting Is Getting Harder for High School Athletes
Why College Track Recruiting Has Become So Difficult for High School Athletes
North Carolina's 2026–27 incoming class offers a revealing look at the new reality of Division I track & field recruiting — and the increasingly crowded marketplace facing high school athletes.
For years, the basic model of college track and field recruiting was relatively straightforward. College coaches graduated seniors, evaluated high school juniors and seniors, and recruited the athletes they believed could develop into future conference scorers.
That model hasn't disappeared.
But it has changed dramatically.
North Carolina's incoming 2026–27 class provides a fascinating example of what today's high school track and field recruit is actually facing.
The story isn't that colleges have stopped recruiting high school athletes. The story is that high school athletes are now competing for roster opportunities in a much larger — and much more accomplished — talent pool.
North Carolina Added 10 College Transfers
UNC announced the addition of 10 transfer athletes for the 2026–27 season. Five came from High Point, while the remaining transfers arrived from Duke, Princeton, Nebraska, Furman and Belmont.
The group includes five pole vaulters, three throwers and two distance athletes. But the number itself only tells part of the story.
Look at the level of athlete entering Chapel Hill.
These Aren't Developmental Prospects
Many of the athletes UNC added have already demonstrated that they can compete successfully at the collegiate level.
Ricardo Montes de Oca
NCAA Indoor First Team All-American, NCAA Outdoor Second Team All-American and multiple-time Big South champion with a 5.70m outdoor personal best.
Emily Romano
NCAA Championships qualifier and Big South champion who arrives with multiple seasons of proven collegiate competition.
Pia Beaulieu
First Team All-Ivy performer who ran 9:52.54 in the steeplechase and established herself as an NCAA-level distance athlete.
Matthew Prebola
2026 ACC champion and First Team All-ACC performer with a personal best of 71.01 meters.
Those athletes represent something fundamentally different from the traditional high school prospect.
They aren't projections.
College coaches already know what they can do.
The High School Recruit's Competition Has Changed
Imagine the decision from a college coach's perspective.
A talented 18-year-old high school athlete may have tremendous upside. But the coaching staff may need two or three years to determine whether that athlete will ultimately become an ACC scorer.
A transfer may arrive having already competed at an NCAA regional, scored at a conference championship, trained successfully in a collegiate program and established verified performances against college competition.
That doesn't automatically make the transfer the better choice.
But it absolutely changes the calculation.
A high school recruit may now be competing against:
The Athlete Hasn't Gotten Worse. The Marketplace Has Gotten Better.
This may be the most important point for families to understand.
A high school athlete can run a performance that historically generated significant Division I recruiting interest and receive a very different response today.
That doesn't necessarily mean the athlete isn't good enough.
The available alternatives for college coaches have changed.
The transfer portal has created something much closer to a national marketplace for established collegiate athletes.
If a coach needs an 800-meter runner, pole vaulter, thrower or distance athlete, that coach no longer has to rely entirely on projecting what a 17-year-old might become.
There may already be a 20-, 21- or 22-year-old college athlete available who has demonstrated exactly what the coach needs.
Being good enough to compete for a program and being recruited by that program are no longer necessarily the same thing.
UNC Is Still Recruiting High School Athletes
This distinction matters.
North Carolina's transfer additions do not mean the program has abandoned traditional high school recruiting. UNC continues to recruit talented high school athletes alongside experienced collegiate transfers.
And that is precisely why this example is so useful.
Modern roster construction isn't high school recruiting or transfer recruiting.
It is both.
A coaching staff can simultaneously develop freshmen for the future while using the transfer market to fill immediate event needs, replace graduating athletes and add proven conference-level performers.
Recruiting Standards Only Tell Part of the Story
This is also why families need to be careful when evaluating published track and field recruiting standards.
A performance can tell you whether an athlete is athletically competitive for a program.
It cannot tell you whether that program actually needs another athlete in that event.
For example, a recruit may appear to meet North Carolina's typical performance benchmarks but encounter a year in which the coaching staff has limited roster availability in that athlete's event group.
That is why recruiting standards should be treated as benchmarks rather than guarantees.
And Another Change May Make This Even More Competitive
The transfer portal isn't the only structural change affecting high school recruiting.
The NCAA's move toward a five-year eligibility model could allow more experienced collegiate athletes to remain in the competitive system longer.
From a roster-construction standpoint, the implications are significant.
A 17-year-old high school senior may increasingly be competing for an opportunity against an athlete who has spent several years training in a college strength program, competing at conference championships and producing verified NCAA performances.
What High School Athletes Need to Do Differently
The biggest mistake families can make in today's environment is assuming that reaching a particular time, height or distance will automatically create recruiting opportunities.
It doesn't work that way anymore.
Build a Wider Recruiting Market
Families should identify schools across several athletic levels rather than constructing an entire college list around historical recruiting standards.
Understand Actual Roster Needs
A school can be an excellent athletic fit on paper and still have little need for another athlete in a particular event during that recruiting cycle.
Start Earlier
By the time a family discovers that its original group of schools doesn't have roster space, many opportunities elsewhere may already be disappearing.
Keep Developing
Performance remains the most powerful recruiting tool available. The faster you run, higher you jump or farther you throw, the more options you create.
Understand Where You Actually Fit
The goal isn't simply to identify the most prestigious college willing to answer an email.
It is to find programs where academics, athletics, roster opportunity and the overall college experience align.
The New Reality of College Track Recruiting
I spent nearly 30 years coaching at the NCAA Division I level, including 20 years as the head coach at Columbia University.
For much of that time, recruiting was primarily about evaluating high school athletes and projecting what they could become in college.
College coaches still do that.
But today's coaches have another option that previous generations of coaches did not have on anything approaching the current scale:
They can recruit athletes who have already proven what they can become.
North Carolina's 2026–27 incoming group illustrates the result.
A major Division I program can recruit talented high school athletes while simultaneously adding conference champions, NCAA qualifiers, All-Americans and experienced athletes from other college programs.
For a college coach, that can be an extremely effective way to construct a roster.
For a 17-year-old trying to earn one of those roster spots, it makes the recruiting process considerably more competitive.
The opportunity is still there.
But understanding where you actually fit — and starting early enough to find that opportunity — has never mattered more.
Not Sure Where You Fit?
Fast Track Recruiting helps athletes and families understand where their performances fit, which programs represent realistic opportunities and how to navigate today's increasingly complicated college recruiting landscape.
Get a Free Recruiting Assessment